Home For the Charmz-Holidays: An Interview with Nygel D. Robinson on Charmz The Other Reindeer

author: Amanda N. Gunther

You know Dasher and Dancer and Prancer and Vixen— Comet and Cupid and Donder and Blitzen— you even know Rudolph! But do you know Charmz? The Other Reindeer? Well now’s your chance! Charmz: The Other Reindeer is making its world premiere this Christmas at Baltimore Center Stage this holiday season. In a TheatreBloom exclusive phone interview, we’re having a chat with Musician and Lyricist Nygel D. Robinson all about the creation of this very special Christmas show.

Thank you so much Nygel, for giving us some of your time, I know it’s quite busy with you still being involved with Mexodus!

Nygel D. Robinson: Thank you for wanting to talk about the show!

Of course! I know a lot of people think that there can’t possibly be much to talk about, it’s a Christmas show so it’s going to be merry, fluffy, and bright!

Nygel: Actually, if we can dive right in with that— I think people assume with holiday shows that it’s going to be totally lighthearted and be a lack of substance. But we were trying really hard with this to have more to that. I think it’s really interesting, because this show mirrors Ken-Matt (librettist and director Ken-Matt Martin) and I a little bit. A couple of years ago with what happened with him in Chicago at VGT, it was a really rough situation. I don’t want to get too into it because I don’t want him to have to relive any of that trauma but it’s an important part of where this comes from. He and I had just met about a year prior to that, he’d been in touch with us about Mexodus and brought us to Chicago, was going to produce the show at his theatre but all that fell apart. After all of that, I started calling him, just checking in, saying ‘hey man, how you doing?’ Because he was in the “New York Times” and “The Chicago Tribune”, and he said “it’s not what you think” and so we had some really real conversations. From that dark part of his life, we ended up becoming really close friends.

We didn’t know it at the time and of course have reflected on it later but unknowingly started writing some of that dynamic into this. Like the relationship dynamic between Rudolph and Charmz. Rudolph is a little like, not quite this washed-up old character but he’s someone who’s ego has gotten in the way and he’s lost the meaning of what that nose means and what Christmas means. He’s starting to lose that magic that makes him special. And Charmz technically has no ‘outward thing’ that makes him special, but he has a heart, he has a song, and he offers all of that to Rudolph, to show him ‘you don’t need all that extra outward stuff to be special.’ And Rudolph gets that back, obviously, but it shows him that he’s worth a lot without the nose.

I love hearing that. I remember seeing the teaser in last year’s Motown Christmas Special for Charmz and I remember thinking that this is going to be a special and unique perspective to Christmas. Where does this idea for, not necessarily a darker take, but a more realistic take on the Christmas holiday come from?

Nygel: Well, Ken-Matt and Stevie (Baltimore Center Stage Artistic Director Stevie Walker-Webb) reached out to me two years ago and said they wanted me to write a musical for Baltimore Center Stage. They wanted a tent-pole project, something they could do every year. They didn’t want to go out and get the rights to The Grinch or do Christmas Carol, everybody does that and the city already has one or two, they wanted to do something in-house that would be specific to Baltimore and to BCS (Baltimore Center Stage.) So we started going back and forth about ideas. Rudolph is enticing, but he comes with licensing for his song and actual story and everything. What is in public domain is the lore around Rudolph. So we thought we could use that and then we could make The North Pole Motown adjacent. Santa Claus will be Barry Gordy adjacent. Rudolph will be Rick James adjacent. And then we made up this new reindeer— Charmz.

They’re all there, Dasher and Dancer and Prancer and all of them. But Ken-Matt split the other eight reindeer into five and three. So you have three of those original eight reindeer who are like The Supremes, and they’re called The Yuletidettes. And then the other five are like The Temptations and they’re called The Mistletones. And the concept is that every year they deliver presents on Christmas Eve but they also do this world-tour-concert. We know it’s ridiculous, right, it’s already ridiculous that Santa Claus and a bunch of reindeer deliver presents to every house on the planet— so why not also do a concert in every city on the planet. And we end up in Baltimore as the last stop on the tour. It makes it very personal to here, but I think we really hit it on the nose— no pun intended— with the name of the reindeer. Charmz. Because this is Charm City.

I love hearing this thought process. And I’m betting there’s a message buried in there somewhere?

Nygel: Oh yes. Because we really started thinking about ‘what do we want to tell children in particular?’ Obviously, this is a family experience, and it’s for everyone, but in knowing the demographic of this city, and working through creating this musical, I realized I really want to talk to black children. There is such importance for these black children to be able to see themselves in a positive way. And seeing the joy that this will bring them, seeing and hearing music that they are familiar with, it’s a really beautiful thing. There’s universality in that specificity. Though I’m trying to talk to them, every child will get that because that’s a child experience. I just need to show a black kid that you don’t have to be the victim of homicide on stage to be seen and represented on stage.

Charmz represents the kid who isn’t in the drama club, the kid who hasn’t had a chance to show what they’ve got. Maybe they just smile really well or maybe you just have a really good hug. But that’s important. And those are things that make you really important in this ecosystem. That’s what Charmz is. He turns out to be this really extraordinary musician, but he doesn’t know it yet, he just started out as this young guy with a song in his heart and a notepad. And no one gave him a chance until this.

Nygel D. Robinson
Nygel D. Robinson

That is truly a beautiful sentiment. Now, how much of the musical numbers and music overall that we as the audience members are about to experience with Charmz is holiday classics or staples that we’re going to recognize, how much of it is written specifically for the show, what’s the balance and blend or ratio there?

Nygel: Everything is original. But what I did, and I will not give myself all the credit, but it’s a pretty special thing. Take “Dancing in the Street”, right? You hear that and you think party. So I thought, “there needs to be a party sequence in this show.” I believe every musical needs a party halfway through Act I. So I took that and ran with it, thinking ‘what is my version of ‘Dancing in the Street?’ and then turned it into Santa Claus throwing a party. I would take a reference song, and say ‘I want it to feel like this’ or have it give this vibe. What I hope is people are sitting there going, ‘who wrote that song? I think that’s a Smokey Robinson song.’ Nope. It’s a Nygel D. Robinson song.

My music director, his name is John Bronston, and John is a good friend of mine in general. He’s also a brilliant, brilliant man. Everywhere I go, I beg him to come with me. He and I worked on orchestrations for this together. One day, we’re at rehearsal and we’re trying to figure out what does it feel like for the horns on a certain song and says “Price is Right!” and I thought “ooh! The Price Is Right!—

Immediately— before you even make the horn sound— that dah-da-da-daaah— I know, and I think many, many people will know exactly what you’re talking about.

Nygel: Exactly. I’m dealing with genius like that. Now we didn’t take that lick, obviously we made up something different, but it feels like that. We were constantly listening to Motown records to see how they used orchestrations and we took from that. So it’s going to feel like they know what the music is but you’ll have actually never heard it before.

I love that. It’s the foundational building of something you know you recognize but also it’s brand new.

Nygel: You know where it came from.

Is there a song in the show that you’re either most proud of or that defines what the meaning of the show is for you?

Nygel: Yep! There’s a song called “Magic Inside” and it’s important for a number of reasons. My partner (Christina Brown) and I were here in Baltimore about a year ago, having a little workshop, and we were trying to come up with a song, and I had told her, “kids…kids…” and I found that it was getting too complicated. And she just said, “Nygel, you’re trying to talk to kids, why are you thinking so hard.” And she’s right. Simple things are often the most profound things.

So we made this song. “…it feels like magic inside and it takes me for a ride and if Santa would see maybe he would soon agree that this magic described might be magic inside of me…” and it’s him realizing that if he can just show Santa what I have, then he’ll see what’s inside of me. And then at the end, we flip it, to the audience, so it’s the magic inside of you all. You have it. You just have to figure out what it is.

I love that too. It’s very reminiscent of the iconic ‘hero is capable of rescuing themselves’ like Dorothy, you had the ability to go home all along, you just had to take the journey to discover that it was within you all along.

Nygel: Yep. And like The Alchemist. You were sitting on the gold the whole time, you just had to go to Egypt. It’s in you.

What is it that the Christmas season means to you when it comes to celebrating with family and friends and how are we seeing that Christmas celebration reflected in the work?

Nygel: It’s community. It’s a party. It’s a celebration. And it’s about getting back to what it was. That’s the problem that the North Pole is having. Even Santa Claus is having that problem, where it’s gotten so much about this world-tour and Christmas Eve that we’ve forgotten what Christmas is actually about. And Ken-Matt wrote really, really beautiful lines about ancient magic and how Christmas used to be about giving people what they needed, not what they wanted. I’m paraphrasing because I don’t want to give too much of it away. But we get so lost in the Amazon-ification of Christmas when it comes to gift-giving that we forget that it’s about showing up for people, being sweet and kind, and just giving something from the heart.

That is a truly beautiful sentiment, a late friend of mine used to say “the greatest present you can give me is the present of your presence.” And I think it’s so important to remind, especially children, that it isn’t about the most expensive Roblox Gift Card, or whatever it is the kids are into these days, but about spending time with your loved ones and sharing that sense of love and community for the holidays.

Nygel: Oh you’re gonna get so much out of Charmz. That’s exactly right. This is about us being together, because this is not forever, and you’ve got to cherish that warm feeling that you get, the excitement that you get, for presents, but for family being there too. It’s easy to conflate the two, but that excitement of family, of friends, of community, especially this time of year, is so, so important. And it can get really one-sided “ooh— presents!” But you need to have that same excitement, “Grandma’s with us this year. Uncle-so-n-so made it home for Christmas this year, or cousin-whoever.”

I couldn’t agree with you more. The holiday season needs a huge spotlight on the importance of being with family, or chosen family, friends and community, in the same way they put all that energy into selling you the latest hot-button item at whatever big-name store they’re selling it at this year.

Nygel: Right!

Nygel, are you performing in this one too?

Nygel: No, no. I’ve just been writing and composing. We’re in rehearsal and I had to go to Chicago. We’re still technically doing Mexodus right now, I had to take two days out to come back out here. I won’t even get to be here at Charmz for opening because we’re closing Mexodus this weekend!

Oh wow! Well, since you’re not in it, if you could be a character in Charmz, who would you want to be and why?

Nygel: I’d want to be Comet. But I can’t tell you why until you see it. I would never do it as well as Antonio Michael Woodard but I would have a lot of fun trying!

See now I’m going to be paying close attention to Comet when I go.

Nygel: Absolutely do. Look for Comet and you will see why I want to play that character.

Do you have a tradition in your family, in your community, in your household that once you do it, Christmas has officially arrived, the season can begin?

Nygel: No, not really because I’ve been a nomad for the past eleven, twelve, or 13 years of my life. But there are new traditions that are starting this year. There are new additions to my life…

Oh! Is that foreshadowing— is that— could that be— a baby!?

Nygel: Yes. There is, in fact, a baby in the digital-human printer.

Oh my gosh!! CONGRATULATIONS!!!!

Nygel: Thank you so much. That’s another reason why this show is so important. It started out as ‘what do I want to tell kids’ and now it’s ‘fuck, what do I want to tell OUR kid?’ It has become a big, emotional roller coaster. When I go into tech, I know I’m going to be walking into a room where I know I’m going to cry. It’s crazy. But there are now some things that my partner has done at home to get ready for Christmas. I said let’s get the tree and we’ll make ornaments and establish that ourselves, and then next year, when this little brown baby comes out, we’ll try to help them make an ornament, but they won’t be old enough to hold it.

And here in Baltimore, these are a lot of our friends, and the ones we didn’t know have become friends. My partner has been here while I was in Chicago. She came to Baltimore because of this feeling of home and tradition, it ties into that question you just asked me. She sent me this video the other day— it’s the music director and two of the actors just sitting in our living room with her, while she’s pregnant, and they’re just on their day off. The kind of care that people are exhibiting here really represents Christmas. And I want to shout that out. It’s really sweet. Because they don’t see her as just an extension of me, they see her as her own person, and they care for her too. It’s got nothing to do with me and that in itself is a tradition. That feeling of we’re around people that we really love, we’re making art, and we’re supporting each other, everybody is looking out for each other. That’s Christmas tradition right there.

What a wonderful way to start celebrating the family and what joy this is going to bring for you and your family and the family that is Baltimore. Why do you want people to come out and see Charmz: The Other Reindeer? We’ve got a lot of Christmas shows, even annual tradition shows, that people can come out and see, so why should people come to this show?

Nygel: Well, we wrote it for Baltimore, so there’s that. If you feel any attachment to this city, that I’m assuming most of your readers are from, then come see your thing that we made for you specifically. It’s new. It’s fun. It’s fast. It’s like an hour and 45. Door to door it’s two hours, though intermission might stretch that a little bit, you know, with families, kids, restrooms, eggnog, and all that. But if the show starts at 7:30 we’re done by 9:30. And we’re trying to tell you something.

I know we’re talking to children with this one, I have a target audience that I make art for, but like I said before, there is universality in this. And everybody needs to hear that there is magic inside of you, even an eighty-year-old, from eight-to-eighty year olds, before that and beyond, you need to hear that. And I find that humans do better watching animals be nice to each other than they do watching humans be nice to each other. We learn better from a Pixar movie than we do a real human movie.

So you’re watching these deer— and they are deer, and they’re acting like deer, they’re a herd of deer. You see them be there for each other, you see them make mistakes, you see them lash out against each other, you see them being mean and evil, but then you also see them make that turnaround. You see them learn to be nicer. I’m trying to tell kids, “you haven’t had a chance to be that mean yet, so try to avoid that.” And I’m telling adults, “I know you’ve all been that mean, because we’ve all been that, let’s rethink how we’re going through situations and do better.”

It’s fun, it’s high-energy. Ken-Matt has written a really, really brilliant, funny colloquial book. There’s a lot of lines you’ll recognize from old classic movies, and the show looks sort of like a Claymation motion. It’s so beautiful. Baltimore is an amazing place and we’re going to show you that with this show, over and over and over again. I love this show more than anything else I’m working on right now, I can’t even lie to you, I just am so excited for this.

Absolutely fabulous! Cannot wait to see it myself! Final question, if you had to sum up your experience of working on Charmz: The Other Reindeer using just one word to encompass the whole project from when it started until now, which one word would you use?

Nygel: Evolution.

Charmz: The Other Reindeer plays through December 27th 2026 in the Pearlstone Theatre of Baltimore Center Stage— 700 N. Calvert Street in the Mt. Vernon neighborhood of Baltimore, MD. For tickets call the box office at 410-332-0033 or purchase them online.


Leave a Reply